I was anticipating an interesting read when I requested this book from NetGalley. A woman in medicine called a “trailblazer” in the description makes a mistake in surgery and now works in a corset factory. And … ends up traveling in a medicine show with her son along with a German giantess, a bow-legged musician, an American Indian poet, and a can-fix-anything man.
What I liked about the story …
- The characters of the giantess, the musician, and the fix-it man. These are not dumped on the reader with full descriptions of each but the characters are built much as a person getting to know more about them as time goes on.
- Huey who was not mentioned above. He is the lead of the medicine show. You know from the beginning that he is lying all the time. And he gets worse as the story goes. His character is key to what happens to everyone else. You will not like him; I didn’t.
- Life in a traveling medicine show. What it took to put up the stage at every stop. What kinds of acts would appeal to people. Huey’s ways of getting poor people in his audience to spend when they shouldn’t. About the care and feeding of people in the traveling caravan (not that Huey cared all that much). And why Huey wanted a “real” doctor in the group.
- The handling of what a hurricane would be like in 1900.
- The friendship that developed among the caravan (sans Huey) and how they found ways to support each other.
Now that’s a good list. BUT … What I did not like …
- The title of the book is The Medicine Woman of Galveston. In the description, “When the show reaches Galveston…” should have read “When the show FINALLY reaches Galveston …” I expected a good section about the book being about how she becomes a “real” doctor in Galveston, the challenges, and yes, triumphs, there. Instead, they arrive just before the end which makes the title — well, flat wrong. It was in THIS section that the book became compelling.
- The name of the doctor — Tucia. Authors, if you want the reader to identify with your lead character, do not give her a weird name. I *still* don’t know if I’m pronouncing right. Maybe if the author had explained why she had such a name … Tucia is also a surname. I know, I know. You probably won’t agree but I never got used to the name all 409 pages.
- Tucia’s panic attacks. There were just too many of them and they sorta got old. The author does explain why she has them.
- Tucia’s pulling out her hair leaving bald spots. I’ve heard of people doing this but like the panic attacks — just too many.
- I kept waiting for Tucia the Real Doctor to show up. Appreciated her workaround to give REAL information out, but longed for a “will the real doctor please stand up” moment.
The five-like list, for this reviewer, did not outweigh the five did-not-like list resulting in a three-star rating. I leave it up to you future reader. You may like this story tremendously. I kept waiting for it to get better.
I received a complimentary DRC (digital review copy) of The Medicine Woman of Galveston via NetGalley from the publisher, Kensington Books | Kensington. A positive review was not required; the opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Rating: 3 stars
Cover: Fits the story.
Pages: 409
Publish Date: 21 May 2024
#TheMedicineWomanofGalveston #NetGalley #AmandaSkenandore
